Who Runs Gov

The Plum LineGreg Sargent's blog

Associated Press Keeps Pushing Inflated Health Care Price Tag Based On Unnamed Source

Wow, it’s the zombie stat that won’t die: It looks like the Associated Press is really committed to its claim — based on an unnamed source — that the House Dems’ health care bill will cost $1.5 trillion.

Yesterday I noted that House Dems were furious with the AP for stating that price tag as outright fact, even though its source was a single anonymous aide and the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office put the cost far lower. Health care reform foes have been reciting the number as if it’s scripture.

Today the AP is at it again:

Votes were planned Thursday in the Education and Labor and Ways and Means committees on a $1.5 trillion plan that majority House Democrats presented this week. The legislation seeks to provide coverage….

Let’s go through this really slowly. It’s possible the plan could end up costing $1.5 trillion. I’m not saying this won’t happen. But right now, this figure is in dispute. On one side is the anonymous aide who gave the AP the number. On the other side are House Dem aides who say on the record that it would cost far less, and the CBO, which estimates $1 trillion.

The point is that even if the $1.5 trillion price tag does turn out to be right, it is not now a matter of outright fact, as the AP keeps asserting. It’s really that simple. More from Brian Beutler and Steve Benen.

This blog’s homepage is here. RSS feed here. Twitter feed here. Email me here.

Posted by Greg Sargent | 07/16/2009, 09:49 AM EST | Categories: House Dems, health care, political media

11 Responses

  1. BBQ | July 16th, 2009 at 10:27 am

    That gosh darn “liberal” media, at it again!

  2. mike from Arlington | July 16th, 2009 at 12:14 pm

    Newt had brought up the medicaid part that wasn’t scored which is supposed to bring the costs down even further.

    Wonder if this is Ben Nelson’s dirty work.

  3. kevo | July 16th, 2009 at 01:05 pm

    Fournier is not an honest person if he allows for such a stuck in the mud response to the criticism leveled at the first citation! What a putz! -Kevo

  4. Kenneth | July 16th, 2009 at 04:21 pm

    Just in: An unnamed source put G. W. Bush present in the White House in May 2006 when numerous farm animals were raped and then ritualistically slaughtered. Secret clean-up crews from the CIA, trained for this very task, were reported to have been called in to remove the mess. Mrs. Bush was heard to exclaim, “Dang it George, you’ve ruined the curtains!”.

  5. News Reference | July 16th, 2009 at 07:15 pm

    Isn’t right winger Rupert Murdoch still on the Associated Press’s Board?

    It was astonishing when the Associated Press appointed an outrageous propagandist like Rupert Murdoch to their board, but in light of the AP’s subsequent reporting, the move has made sense.

  6. DeeseoristE | September 14th, 2009 at 04:02 am

    Hello,мооаоквеуі xanax anxiety
    Xanax And How It Helps Those Suffering From Anxiety
    Order low cost Xanax medication online and save your money! No RX!
    Xanax is a drug belonging to the group called benzodiazepines.
    xanax price
    It has certain effects which could cause chemicals in the brain that may become unbalanced and cause anxiety.
    http://medseaproperty.com/ – purchase xanax

    Medications like this should not be given to anyone below 18 years old.

  7. alisonsnap | October 9th, 2009 at 06:21 am

    alternatives radiative year business 103

  8. elmoorterr | October 9th, 2009 at 06:22 am

    water africa fourth notes alternatives

  9. kaileycoll | October 18th, 2009 at 06:27 am

    action trend found area reliable oceans

  10. randolphst | October 18th, 2009 at 06:27 am

    emission tropical microblogging lime methane pdf 1990 warms 1980 until differing

  11. deverehyat | October 18th, 2009 at 06:28 am

    concerns content leading roughly first serious www seen

Leave a Reply


Please email us at profiles@whorunsgov.com to bring to our attention any content or conduct that you believe violates our Discussion and Submission Policy.